When Inclusion Becomes Erasure: How Colleges Are Redefining Equity

Woman with long dark curly hair wearing a dark cardigan over a white top, smiling at camera outdoors

Healthcare professionals collaborate while reviewing patient information on tablet in medical facilityWhat happens when the language created to combat institutional inequality is co-opted and used to replicate the very circumstances it was created to dismantle?

This is what's happening in modern education. Whether intentionally or unintentionally, I have noticed a trend: educational institutions are increasingly weaponizing the language of diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) to legitimize decisions that harm the very communities these frameworks were created to help.

As a practitioner in a nonprofit serving community colleges, I have observed more than one institution use terms like inclusion, intersectionality, and equity to justify eliminating identity-specific programming and spaces. These terms are being used in ways that contradict their traditional definitions and purposes.

Equity is being redefined as providing the same support to everyone, regardless of disparity and need, rather than allocating resources based on needs or barriers. Intersectionality is being used to argue that several marginalized identities should occupy the same space, instead of preventing intersectional erasure or explaining how overlapping systems of oppression create distinct experiences of marginalization and privilege. Likewise, belonging is being used rhetorically while the tangible resources that support it are being removed.

This is forcing programs and spaces, developed to rectify past harms, to close or serve everyone, thereby reducing the support for their intended populations. This trend is not isolated to the institutions I serve. It is national.

What's wrong with untargeted diversity, inclusion, and belonging programs and spaces?

Universalizing limited resources to help all students can diminish support for underserved groups. When historically underrepresented students, who are often small percentages of the population and significantly underrepresented within both the student body and faculty, lose or are pressured to share the one campus space where they are centered, they can become a minority even in spaces specifically created to ensure their representation.

Additionally, consolidating several marginalized group spaces into one can eliminate their intended purposes. Identity-specific centers often serve a different purpose than multicultural centers. They are not just spaces where specific groups congregate. They are meant to be counterspaces and environments where specific identities’ experiences, histories, cultures, and needs are purposefully centered.

These centers are supposed to provide community, peer support, identity-affirming programming, and a space where individuals can express themselves without constantly having to explain or validate their identities or experiences. This applies to gender, race, and sexual orientation-centered spaces. Centering everyone can result in centering no one. Moreover, aggregating disaggregated groups can create serious issues.

The Issues consolidation

Consolidation can lead to competition for scarce resources. Reduced staff, budgets, and programming calendars could force students to compete for attention, funding, programming time, representation, and institutional recognition, potentially resulting in inequalities and discrimination. Even without intentional discrimination, resources and attention might disproportionately favor populations with larger numbers, more institutional power, or more outspoken supporters. This can cause centers to reproduce, rather than resolve, asymmetrical power dynamics among historically oppressed populations.

Consolidation could also result in some groups losing their cultural ownership and sense of psychological safety. Representation in a multicultural space does not equate to a community having a dedicated space where it dictates its own culture, programming, and priorities. If a space lacks representation or is occupied by individuals who express animosity or even a lack of warmth towards some groups, it could be physically accessible without feeling affirming or safe for everyone. This is the central issue with creating a space that purports to serve all: centering one group could undermine support for another. There is a difference between a setting open to serving and affirming a vulnerable group's needs and one intentionally structured to consistently center, serve, and protect them.

True consolidation would require maintaining separate budgets, specialized personnel, targeted programming, and adequate space to support differing needs. Without these, consolidated spaces risk dismantling the purpose of identity-affirming spaces, even if physical access is preserved.

The co-option of DEI language

Most alarmingly, beyond the dilution of DEI program objectives, the very language created to advance equity is being inverted and used to legitimize practices that undermine its original purpose. Policies, programs, and centers established to combat exclusion and underrepresentation are now being labeled racist or discriminatory for prioritizing the very students they were designed to assist. Divorced from their purposes, definitions, and theoretical foundations, the language initially employed to identify and confront injustice is being turned against the very interventions developed to address it.

This is partly because administrators and students, who often comprise the majority of the campus population, representation, and leadership, are claiming it's unfair, inequitable, and in some cases even discriminatory, for underrepresented and historically marginalized students to have even one dedicated program or space on campus where they are the majority.

As a result, spaces are reverting to pre-existing multicultural centers, an organizational model whose limitations originally necessitated the development of dedicated spaces. This demonstrates how true equity can be obscured when its purpose and policies are interpreted and applied without considering the circumstances that necessitated their development.

Equity Language as a Tool of Retrenchment

Using equity language without equity practices can result in performative equity. Such practices can lead institutions to abandon targeted investments in equity initiatives while simultaneously invoking their principles. They might claim to offer inclusive programming that serves all students, even as they remove dedicated spaces, resources, and culturally responsive support systems designed to address the distinct needs and disparities historically marginalized groups face.

Furthermore, using this language without the necessary practices can neutralize individuals' capacity to challenge inequality, as institutions can argue they already implement equity initiatives. Thus, they can use equity language to present a veneer of equality and progressiveness, while their practices weaken and retract equitable outcomes.

This is not a critique of consolidation per se, as resource sharing is not intrinsically inequitable. Equity initiatives should, however, be assessed based on their consequences, not legitimized by their language.

Using equity language alone does not make practices equitable. If institutions are sincere, they must cease measuring their commitments by what they state and start analyzing what their decisions do.